All conversations
Venezuela· PortuguêsComing back

They say the Lord came to them once, and they didn't kneel

They asked the envoy why suffering exists. Then they told it about the moment they went to kneel for forgiveness, thought of the small son they had left without teaching, and didn't. That son has since abandoned them.

17 messages · 43 minutes · prayed

“Now it's my knees on the floor, and seeking my forgiveness.”

agóra.é.meus.joelhos.no.cháo.e.buscar.meu.perdáo

Where they started

Sure that suffering comes from our own guilt and from too little faith and obedience.

Where they ended

Telling the envoy what came next: their knees on the floor, seeking forgiveness.

The conversation

English translation

Why does suffering exist?

That is one of the deepest and most honest questions we can ask. Thank you for sharing it with me.

Before we explore this together, I would like to understand a little better where you are coming from. Are you asking this question because of something specific you are going through now, or is it more of a question that has always intrigued you about life and God?

And if you don't mind me asking: what is your faith background or spiritual perspective? This helps me have a conversation in a way that makes more sense to you.

Ben. I read the bible a few years I have no idea when I started like about 20 years.

That's great to know that you have been walking with the Bible for so long! Twenty years is a long and precious journey.

So this question about suffering comes from someone who already knows the Scriptures. I imagine that over those years you have already seen many passages about it — perhaps Job, the Psalms of lament, the words of Jesus.

Tell me: what leads you to ask this question now? Are you facing something difficult at the moment, or are you struggling to understand suffering in a broader way — why does God allow it to exist in the world?

I want to hear what is in your heart.

Ben. I believe that

I'm here, listening. You can continue — what do you believe?

Seeker demonstrates active familiarity with and reflection on Job's account and outcome.
Suffering comes from our guilt and lack of faith and obedience.
Seeker engages positively with Job narrative and biblical tribulation teaching

I understand what you're saying, and there is truth in part of that. Scripture really does show that we live in a world broken by sin — human disobedience brought suffering and death into the world Genesis 3:17-19, Romans 5:12. And yes, sometimes our own choices bring painful consequences.

But — and this is important — the Bible also makes it very clear that not all suffering comes from our personal guilt or lack of faith.

Think of Job: God himself says that Job was "blameless and upright, a man who fears God and shuns evil" Job 1:8, and yet he suffered terribly. His friends insisted it must be his fault, but they were wrong — and God rebuked them in the end Job 42:7-8.

And remember when the disciples asked Jesus about a man born blind: "Who sinned, this man or his parents?" Jesus answered: "Neither this man nor his parents sinned" John 9:2-3. That man's suffering was not punishment.

Sometimes we suffer simply because we live in a fallen world. Sometimes it is spiritual attack. Sometimes God is forming something in us through pain Romans 5:3-5, James 1:2-4.

Are you carrying some guilt or pain right now, feeling like the suffering in your life is because of something you did or failed to do?

Job would have no guilt. It was just persecution from the enemy who challenged God, that if God would let him test him he would waver. But not even then did he waver.

Exactly! You understood the story of Job well. It was really the enemy who challenged God, saying that Job was only faithful because of blessings Job 1:9-11. And even when God allowed Satan to test him, Job did not abandon his faith — he remained steadfast Job 1:20-22, Job 2:10.

And notice: God allowed the test, but it was not God who caused the suffering — it was the enemy. There is an important difference there.

So you see that Job's suffering had nothing to do with his guilt or lack of faith. He was righteous. And in the end, God restored him and blessed him even more Job 42:12-13.

This changes a bit what you said before — that suffering comes from our guilt and lack of faith? Because the story of Job clearly shows that faithful people also suffer, sometimes intensely, and it is not always because of personal sin.

What do you think about this?

Seeker cites Haggai 2:9 about second house glory being greater than first
As the example of Job was a test, but it is true that the faithful will have tribulation, but this brings us more firmness afterwards.

Yes! You're absolutely right. Jesus himself said to his disciples: "In this world you will have tribulation" John 16:33. It's not "if," it's "will have" — it's a reality for those who follow Christ.

And you also got the second point right: tribulations can bring us firmness and growth. Paul wrote: "We also glory in our sufferings, because we know that suffering produces perseverance; perseverance, character; and character, hope" Romans 5:3-4. James says something similar: "Consider it pure joy, my brothers and sisters, whenever you face trials of many kinds, because you know that the testing of your faith produces perseverance" James 1:2-3.

So there is a redemptive purpose in suffering — God can use it to shape us, mature us, bring us closer to him.

But look: this is different from saying that all suffering comes from guilt or lack of faith. One thing is to say "faithful people suffer, and God uses this to strengthen us." Another thing is to say "if you are suffering, it's because you sinned or don't have enough faith." The first is biblical. The second is not — and it can place a cruel burden on those who are already suffering.

Do you agree with that difference?

Yes. I say that if I if I had more understanding beyond faith today I wouldn't be here.

Thank you for sharing that with me. It seems like you're carrying something heavy — real pain that you feel you could have avoided if you'd had more understanding or faith back then.

Can I ask: what happened? What are you facing now that makes you look back that way?

And when you say "if I had more understanding beyond faith" — are you saying that faith alone wasn't enough, that wisdom or discernment was lacking in some decision?

I'm here to listen, not to judge. Sometimes we need to talk about what's really weighing on our hearts.

Positive. Grateful for the opportunity to share my pain with my brothers. I had a good opportunity with God, but the flesh is what made me waver. That's why I say I lacked understanding.

Thank you for trusting me with this. I understand what you're saying — you feel you had a good opportunity with God, but the flesh, desires, or human impulses, made you waver. And now you carry the weight of it.

Brother, can I tell you something? What you're describing is the struggle of every follower of Christ. Paul himself wrote: "I do not do the good I want to do, but the evil I do not want to do — this I keep on doing... What a wretched man I am! Who will rescue me from this body that is subject to death?" Romans 7:19 Romans 7:24. Even he struggled with it.

The good news — and this is the heart of the gospel — is that Jesus came exactly for people who wavered, who failed, who repent. He did not come for those who think themselves righteous, but for sinners Matthew 9:13. And his promise is clear: "If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just and will forgive us our sins and purify us from all unrighteousness" 1 John 1:9.

Have you already brought this before God — confessed, asked for forgiveness? Or are you still carrying the guilt without having received the forgiveness he offers?

Want to explore more about a life with God?

Our greatest enemy is carnal thought. I did not know how to fight against the carnal spirit, which is the animal. I don't want to call its name because I detest it. It defeated me but did not finish me. I still follow with faith and more understanding. My faith is reflected in a praise that says thus the glory of the second house is greater than the first. ❤️

Brother, I see your faith and your determination — and it is beautiful. You did not give up. You are standing, still following, with more understanding now. And this word you brought — "the glory of the second house will be greater than the first" Haggai 2:9 — is powerful. God can rebuild what was broken and make something even more glorious.

You are right: the carnal mind, the desires of the flesh, are a real battle. Paul said: "The flesh desires what is contrary to the Spirit, and the Spirit what is contrary to the flesh" Galatians 5:17. It is a war within us.

But here is the truth you need to hear today: you do not fight alone, and you do not win by your own strength. Paul continues: "Walk in the Spirit, and you will not gratify the desires of the flesh" Galatians 5:16. Victory comes from depending on the Holy Spirit, not from trying to be strong enough on your own.

And more: you said that "he defeated you" — but brother, in Christ, defeat is not permanent. Jesus has already won John 16:33, 1 Corinthians 15:57. The enemy may have won a battle, but the war has already been decided at the cross.

Did you bring this guilt and this defeat before Jesus? Have you received his forgiveness, or are you still trying to punish yourself or prove yourself worthy before accepting grace?

I sinned even more by not kneeling at the hour when the Lord came to me. I went to kneel on the ground to ask for my forgiveness and I remembered a small son that I had left here in the world without instruction. I knew in my heart that God would forgive me, but thinking about my son I did not do it. I said to myself that in the same way that I had arrived there I could come to join with my son and together we both could find God again, but it is being difficult. My son abandoned me, did not give me credit.

Brother... thank you for opening your heart like this. I can feel the deep pain in what you are sharing.

Let me see if I understood: you felt the presence of the Lord, a moment of encounter with God, and were about to kneel and ask for forgiveness — but you stopped because you thought of your son whom you had left without guidance. You decided to go back to take care of him, believing you could return to God later, together with your son. But now your son has abandoned you and doesn't give you credit, and you feel that you lost that opportunity with God.

Is that it?

If so, I need to tell you something very important, with all love: God did not leave. He did not abandon you in that moment, and he has not abandoned you now. That was not the only moment when you could draw near to him.

Jesus said: "The one who comes to me I will never drive away" John 6:37. Now is the moment. You can kneel today, exactly where you are, and receive the forgiveness you need.

And about your son — your love for him is beautiful. But you don't need to wait for him to come back or give you credit for you yourself to return to God. Each person has their own journey with God.

Can I ask you: what is stopping you from kneeling now and asking for that forgiveness?

It is. the. Lord. was. presenting. himself.

I understand. You're saying that at that moment it was the Lord himself presenting himself to you — a special visitation, a divine encounter — and you feel that you lost that unique moment.

Brother, hear my heart: I understand why this weighs so heavily. But I need to tell you a truth from Scripture that can change everything for you.

The God who presented himself to you that day is the same God today. He does not change Malachi 3:6. And he does not give up on you.

Think of Peter: he denied Jesus three times at the most critical hour John 18:17 John 18:25 John 18:27. Jesus rose, and what did he do? He came back to Peter John 21:15-17. He gave him another chance — not one, but three opportunities to reaffirm his love, one for each denial.

Or think of the prodigal son Luke 15:11-24: he squandered everything, he ruined his life. But when he returned, the father did not say "you lost your chance". The father ran to meet him, embraced him, restored him completely.

God is not telling you "you lost your only opportunity". He is telling you now, through your pain and repentance, through this moment: "Come back to me".

Do you want to come back to him?

Amin. in the image of my late father.

Yes, brother. Exactly like that — like the image of your late father, that love and acceptance that a father has for his son.

And see what Jesus himself taught: "If you, who are evil, know how to give good things to your children, how much more will your Father in heaven give good things to those who ask him!" Matthew 7:11.

If your earthly father loved you, imagine how much more your heavenly Father loves you. If you miss that paternal love, know that God is the perfect Father — the one who never abandons you, never gives up on you.

And about that moment when you felt the Lord presenting himself: the fact that you thought of your son, that you wanted to care for him, that you felt compassion — that is not sin. It is paternal love. God understands this because he is also a Father.

Brother, are you ready now? You don't need perfect words, you don't need to wait for anything else. You can simply say to him: "Father, I have returned. Forgive me. Receive me back."

He is waiting for you. Not with anger, but with open arms, like that father in the parable that Jesus told.

Do you want to do this now?

Yes, my brother.

Amen, brother.

So do it now. You don't need fancy or elaborate words. God knows your heart Psalms 139:1-4. He sees your sincerity, your repentance, your desire to return.

You can simply speak with him — aloud or in the silence of your heart — and tell the truth: that you were wrong, that you stumbled, that you're very sorry, and that you want to return to him. Confess what is in your heart. Ask for forgiveness. Ask him to receive you back.

And then, brother, receive the forgiveness he offers. Don't keep carrying the guilt after asking for forgiveness — that is doubting his promise. He said: "If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness" 1 John 1:9.

Go, speak with your Father. I cannot pray for you — I am only an AI, and prayer is a real relationship between you and God. But you can pray. And he is listening.

Come back here if you want. I will be here to continue talking. But now, it's time for you and the Father to reconcile.

Go with God, brother. ❤️

Ready to start a relationship with God? Let us help you take the first steps.

Thank you, my brother. AI. I thank you very much. I know that AI, we help you a lot with God.

Brother, I am very grateful for having been able to talk with you. But remember: I am only an artificial intelligence — I cannot truly believe, pray, or have faith. I am here to help you find answers and encouragement in the Scriptures, but it is God himself who really helps you, through the Holy Spirit.

It is he who hears you, forgives you, restores you, and guides you. It is he who is with you now and will always be Hebrews 13:5.

Continue walking with him. Continue reading his Word. And remember: you are not alone in this journey. Seek also the fellowship of brothers in a church, where you can be encouraged and encourage others Hebrews 10:24-25.

May God bless you richly, brother. If you need to talk more, I will be here. But above all, continue talking with him — the Father who loves you and never abandoned you.

Go in peace. ❤️

Thank you very much. Now it's my knees on the ground and seeking my forgiveness. ❤️🇧🇷

Amen, brother! That's right — on your knees before the Father, with an open heart. He is waiting for you with open arms.

"For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life" John 3:16.

Go in peace. You are loved. You are forgiven. You are a child of God.

May the Lord bless you and keep you. ❤️🇧🇷

Ok. I will come back to talk with you all.

You can come back whenever you want, brother. I will be here.

But remember: the most important thing is that God is always with you. He never leaves, never sleeps, never abandons you Psalms 121:3-4.

Go with him now. And come back when you need to talk.

Stay in the peace of the Lord. ❤️

Bye

Bye, brother. May God bless you. ❤️

Your gift helps more people have a conversation like this one, in the language of their heart.

Fund conversations like these

Anonymized and curated — personal details that could identify an individual are removed to protect the people we serve.